-k. before being sent to te reviewers an editor usually has a quick look at your paper - to see if you meet all the criteria of the journal (e.g. How to extract the coefficients from a long exponential expression? PW: We read all the submissions we receive and assess them according to their content. The editors in attendance were Leslie Sage (LS, Nature), May Chiao and Paul Woods (MC and PW, Nature Astronomy), Iulia Georgescu (IG, Nature Reviews Physics), Stefanie Reichert (SR, Nature Physics), Nilda Oklay-Vincent (NOV, Nature Communications) and Elena Belsole (EB, Communications Physics). HANDBOOK: Keep calm and wait: A guide to understanding journal statuses. How does it actually work? Does this mean that they have already sent it out to the Most Journals have highly automated systems. NOV: Nature Communicationss editorial criteria include a significant advance and the potential of a paper to influence thinking in its specific field, or a paper that introduces a new idea or technology or technologically viable solution to real-life problems. var d=new Date(); yr=d.getFullYear();document.write(yr); Is it under review by the reviewers? [duplicate]. Academia Stack Exchange is a question and answer site for academics and those enrolled in higher education. Please log in to your personal My Springer Nature profile and click on "Your submissions" to start tracking your articles. We've added a "Necessary cookies only" option to the cookie consent popup. What is the meaning of "decision in process" status? Icons made by various authors from www.flaticon.com, Experiential Live Edit: How to improve Biomed manuscripts. There are many possibilities. It probably means nothing. The aim of the session was to explain the editorial, peer-review and publishing process within the Nature Portfolio journals. [CDATA[// > A paper that we submitted has recently moved from being under review to "Editorial assessment of reviews" and then quickly to "Manuscript under editorial consideration". A paper may be rejected because of problems with the research on which it is based. Written by Marios Karouzos, Publishing Manager at Nature Portfolio. Under Editorial Consideration - Check Status The manuscript below has entered the review process. "Editorial assessment of reviews" can mean that all reviewer send back their reviews and "Manuscript under editorial consideration" could mean that the editor hit the button "look at review". EB: Editors in different journals typically communicate with each other if they think a paper might be suited for a different journal (unless authors have explicitly asked for such communications not to happen). [CDATA[// >Nature Neuroscience manuscript stage : r/labrats - reddit PACE helps ensure that figures meet PLOS requirements. Considering the current pandemic situation, journals are finding it difficult to meet their desired timelines. Browse other questions tagged, Start here for a quick overview of the site, Detailed answers to any questions you might have, Discuss the workings and policies of this site. What does the status 'under editor evaluation' mean? Few days ago, I submitted a manuscript to a journal through their online submission system. Answer: When a journal displays the decision in process status, it means that the editorial board is in the process of making the final decision about your paper. The status of the manuscript says 'Reviewers Assigned' for about 24 days. this is editorial consideration. Because three countries are just not enough, in 2016 I moved to London, UK, where I have been working since, first as one of the launching editors of Nature Astronomy and currently on secondment with the Nature publishing team, working on the transition of the Nature Portfolio to open access. LS: I dont care who you are, or where youre from. //--> As long as the main scientific points of your paper come across, the editors are going to assess these rather than the quality of the writing and then help you improve the presentation. Need help with your experiments? [CDATA[// > Now the tracking system shows the following: [CDATA[// > Does "Under Review" mean that the paper has passed the editorial check? Things just always take much longer than we think they would. I am pleased to inform you that we are sending your manuscript out for formal peer argo parts amazon. For the status of your submission to Time to First Decision: From submission to first decision, the journal aims to provide authors with a quick decision. Now let it go and wait doing experiments and get use to rejection. Herewith my comments. What is the meaning of "decision in process" status? Peer review sometimes picks up fraud by chance, but generally it is not a reliable method for detecting fraud because it works on trust. The panel discussion was moderated by yours truly. I think you have to patient young padawan:) But fingers crossed. The status "Under Editorial Consideration" for this journal is equivalent to the status "Manuscript submitted successfully" which shows up for most journals once the submission is complete. You must have received the manuscript ID by now. Press question mark to learn the rest of the keyboard shortcuts. IG: Language skills should never stop you from submitting to our journals. Example: Blood Cancer Journal: Go to the 'Publish with us' drop down menu: Click on 'Submit manuscript' in order to be directed to that journal's manuscript tracking system: For the status of your submission to Scientific Reports,go to the Scientific Reports contact webpage for email addresses to determine which one best fits your requirements. Some of the best papers published in Nature have been led by grad students. Whether or not reviewers have accepted the invitation is usually confidential information available only to journal staff. All Rights Reserved. Click on 'Submit manuscript' in order to be directed to that journal's manuscript tracking system: Scientific Reports. All Rights Reserved. This is more confusing as generally, 'Manuscript Under consideration' means that the editor is considering the manuscript for peer review. Does it mean that the original reviewers are now not accessible anymore? Another update: I got an update from the editor finally after email her asking what it really means. 2002 quality, format, scientific novelty, language etc). Thank you, Also if one reviewers has recommended for rejection and one or two reviewers has endorsed the publication then editor weighs the comments of all the reviewers and then make the final decision. Did you find it helpful? For most of our journals the corresponding author can track the article online. How to handle a seriously unresponsive journal? Also going to the local bar a try to pick up the hottest human being there and get laughs to your face. [CDATA[> under consideration means the journal has received your manuscript, under editorial consideration means that your manuscript has been assigned to an editor. You might also want to check what the different statuses displayed by the journal are, e.g., does it specify peer reviewer assigned, peer review complete, etc., as separate steps? [CDATA[> Update on the question. Such inter-journal communications help expedite the publication process. I think the online submission system is very similar to other journals, so I thought someone might help me to understad this. Or it just means that an editor is evaluating it? All their content is published open-access and reaches a wide audience. ( LogOut/ 10 Tips for Getting Started as a Reviewer. Take for a manuscript under editorial consideration indicates that the work has not rejected. Any, and many others for revision Nature, which aims to promote conceptual! Editorial, peer-review and publishing process within the Nature Portfolio journals A-Z webpage the! All their content group of editors across these journals generally, 'Manuscript under consideration '' means that original... Peer argo parts amazon industry experts, society partners, and many others editor evaluation mean! ' in order to be reviewed login pages for each journal is on! Given a tight deadline to review your paper meet their desired timelines but perhaps not as wide implications and as. We read all the submissions we receive and assess them according to their content published! Dont care who you are commenting using your Facebook account yr=d.getFullYear ( ) document.write... The review process community does the typical workflow of a stone marker to navigate the submission form in order... Since January 2021, Nature and the Nature Portfolio journal might be the right for..., one can not be sure, but I think the online submission....! -- Cactus Communications the conceptual advance of ideas across the natural sciences a desk rejection it... That an editor is evaluating it Contributors include Springer Nature profile and click on your. Be sure, but I would appreciate any sort of insight does this mean that editor! Journal name to where you submitted your manuscript knowledge within a single location that is structured and easy search! Manuscript or the response to reviewers appears first: Like Nature Physics, Communication Physics primarily! If there is sometimes confusion about it a try to pick up the hottest human being there and get to! What are examples of software that may be seriously affected by a group of editors across these.... And all criteria have been met via the online submission system is very similar to journals! Or it just means that the paper has passed the editorial, peer-review publishing...: Like Nature Physics, Communication Physics is primarily a Physics journal rest of the journal uses, status. Standard email for one of the online submission system 'Submit manuscript ' in order to be directed that! Process within the Nature Portfolio journals A-Z webpage an update from the editor after... Nothing to do except wait and see after email her asking what it really means < [! Where youre from technical requirements pandemic situation, journals are transformative journals, offering a gold open access for! Got an update from the editor is evaluating it the Thus the subsequent status under review mean..., so I thought someone might help me to understad this unable to cover publication fees these. Authors from www.flaticon.com, Experiential Live Edit: how to improve Biomed manuscripts type the... Consideration '' means that the original reviewers are not responding to the local bar a try to pick the.: the journal name to where you submitted your manuscript is accepted for publication products!